A Simple Thanksgiving Menu … Turkey, Optional
This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure policy.
If it were not for my sister, lover of pie, peeps and cranberry sauce, Thanksgiving this year would amount to stuffing, rolls, and bread pudding — the book deadline is rapidly approaching. I’m embarrassed to admit this, but about a month ago, I called my sister asking if she wanted to meet halfway at a restaurant this year. My sister would not stand for it, and so she is hosting, and my sole contribution will be punch.
If I were to host Thanksgiving, however, this is what I would serve:
Butternut squash lasagna, the star of last year’s Thanksgiving in VT, brought to the table by a vegetarian friend, who kindly passed along the old Gourmet recipe. It has become one of my favorites.
Philadelphia Fish House punch, a favorite party trick all times of the year, is a must. If you’ve been enlisted with the merry making, and want to get ahead, here’s a plan: squeeze the lemon juice and make the simple syrup now, and freeze both until turkey day (or the day before to allow time to thaw) along with a bundt pan filled with water for the ice ring. In the meantime, stock up on rum and cognac.
On the side: Alice Waters’ Potato Gratin, a long-time family fave, another one known to outshine the turkey.
Bread: These no-knead thyme dinner rolls are a snap to throw together and bake while the turkey rests:
Though biscuits are fun, too:
Red wine cranberry sauce, an old Sally Schneider favorite :
Stuffing: made on a sheetpan stuffing to ensure a high ratio of crispy edges to creamy center.
Centerpiece: a bowl of quince,
which can be turned into membrillo or jam, which make wonderful gifts for the holidays.
Desserts:
Basic apple pie, dough made in food processor — dough can be made now and frozen:
Pumpkin shmumpkin, squash has more flavor: Ronnie Hollingsworth’s Most Excellent Squash Pie:
Two other favorites that can be made ahead of time and get better by the day: Chez Panisse Almond Torte and Orange and Olive Oil cake.
All of these recipes are compiled on This PDF for easy printing.
Many more Thanksgiving ideas can be found here.
Also, more desserts, salads and sides.
Wishing you all a fun and relaxing holiday. Happy Happy Thanksgiving.
xo
This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure policy.
12 Comments on “A Simple Thanksgiving Menu … Turkey, Optional”
This all looks so fabulous! I agree with your sister 100%. If I had a sister like you who can cook like you do, no restaurant would ever do for holidays. Ha! I laugh at the suggestion. These suggestions are making my mouth drool and I can’t wait to make some of them. I can’t help myself… They might not make it to the Thanksgiving table, but they’ll definitely make it to the autumn/winter dinner table. Yum!
Thank you, Dana! I know, I mean, I have zero interest in spending Thanksgiving at a restaurant, so I am grateful my sister put her foot down. Going out to eat with 8 toddlers, however, would have been quite an experience. Thank you for the kind words. Happy Thanksgiving to you and your family!
Alexandra–What a lovely display of quince! So simple and elegant. Your PDF is much appreciated. I’ve made the torte and the orange olive oil cake so many times with great success. The fish house punch is perfect for mellowing rambunctious relatives, and the cranberry sauce is so much more interesting in flavor than the following the package directions. I’ve made your rolls and apple pie and potato gratin and the squash lasagne, which please vegetarian and non-vegetarian alike–obviously you’ve inspired my family and me. Now I’m going to try the squash pie! It looks superb. Thank you for all the gifts of your recipes, and Happy Thanksgiving to you and your family.
Thank you for your kind words, Liz! And Happy Thanksgiving to your family as well.
Your suggestions look wonderful. Truth be known, I would have been happy with your stuffing, rolls and bread pudding menu! Sorry, turkey.
Looking forward to your book!
Happy Thanksgiving to you and yours.
Thank you so much, Trish! This means so much. Happy Thanksgiving to you and your family!
Simple is the way to go for the holidays this year, for sure. I still need to try the butternut squash lasagna – maybe post Thanksgiving? – but, my contribution for Thursday is going to be those sweet potatoes you just recently posted, the ones with lime and cilantro. I made them last week, and roasted the potatoes as slices rather than mash it all together, and it was delicious! So much brighter and more SoCal than casserole. Happy Thanksgiving to you and your family!
Katie, this makes me so happy! Love the idea of roasting the potatoes as slices — seems more inline withe original spirit of the dish, and yes, very SoCal. Love it. Happy Thanksgiving to you and your family as well!
I never eat turkey on thanksgiving- too many other delicious items on the menu. I love the butternut squash idea as a main course- it is so delicious and I have been asked for the recipe every time I serve it.
So happy to hear this, Holly! Happy Thanksgiving to you and your family!
Good luck with your book deadline, my friend. You got this.
So how did it go wrapping up your manuscript? I had been thinking of you. This ^ ^ is such a good list, I have made several of these wonderful things to eat 🙂 And I made the potato gratin again just this past weekend for my Christmas Ham Dinner Party for Twenty (why? why??). No potato leftovers! Success!!