Little Gems with Chez Panisse Green Goddess Dressing
This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure policy.
I understand I am very late to the game here, but I can’t help but sing the praises of little gem lettuces, which appeared at nearly every restaurant I found myself in last month, most memorably at Pizzaiolo in Oakland. There, the little gems were tossed with watermelon radishes, avocado, and a lightly creamy, tarragon-heavy, green goddess dressing. The salad tasted so fresh and bright — so California! — that despite the many delicious morsels that followed — meatballs in red sauce (seriously the best), slow-cooked rapini, two pizzas, and affogato — I continue to dream about that salad.
But, as noted, I am not alone in my admiration for little gems, which look like mini heads of romaine and taste sweet. When I recounted the details of my meal at Pizzaiolo to Jeffrey, the food stylist of the Bread. Toast. Crumbs. shoot, he listened intently then shared with enthusiasm his favorite party trick: cut heads of little gems into wedges and arrange on a platter with various homemade dips and sauces. I love this idea. What a nice way to manage allergies and aversions, to try to please everyone.
I returned home with green goddess dressing on the brain and, knowing Pizzaiolo’s lineage, opened Chez Panisse Vegetables. The green goddess dressing in CPV begins, as nearly all of their dressings do, with macerating shallots and garlic in vinegar. Why this simple step works I don’t quite know — maybe the vinegar draws out the sweetness of the shallots, maybe it tempers their bite, maybe it quickly pickles them — but it’s one of the best techniques I’ve learned from a cookbook, and something I do now with every salad I make, whether it be composed of grains, beans, vegetables, or greens.
To no surprise, the CPV green goddess dressing defies convention, omitting mayonnaise and sour cream in favor of olive oil and heavy cream (just a little). Many herbs can be used, but I love it when the predominant flavor is tarragon, as it is prepared at Pizzaiolo.
On my first visit back to my co-op after being in CA, I spotted dozens of little gems sitting with the salad greens — they’ve likely been there all along — and so I picked up a few tubs. I’ve since been tossing them in salads with the green goddess dressing but also doing what Jeffrey suggested, quartering them through the core and arranging them on a board. No need to mess with such a good thing.
Here’s how to make the Chez Panisse Vegetables green goddess dressing: Macerate shallots and garlic in vinegar, then mash in minced anchovies and half an avocado:
Slowly whisk in olive oil, a little cream, and a ton of herbs:
Serve it with little gems as an appetizer:
or make a salad:
Chez Panisse Vegetables Green Goddess Dressing
- Total Time: 10 minutes
Description
Source: Chez Panisse Vegetables
As noted above, this dressing is great as a dip for crisp vegetables or wedges of little gem lettuces or tossed with any greens for a simple salad.
Ingredients
- 1 shallot
- 1 clove garlic
- 1/4 cup white balsamic vinegar
- ½ lemon
- ½ lime
- 2 anchovies, finely minced, optional—I never use anchovies anymore
- 1 avocado
- ¾ cup olive oil
- ½ cup cream, optional—I never use the cream anymore
- a ton (at least 1 cup) of chopped herbs such as parsley, tarragon, cilantro, basil, and chives
- Salt and Pepper
Instructions
- Peel and chop fine the shallot and garlic and macerate in the vinegar, a big squeeze of lemon, and a smaller one of lime. Add 1/2 teaspoon kosher salt. Let sit for at least 10 minutes.
- Add the anchovy, if using, and the flesh of the avocado. Mash together with a fork. Whisking with the fork, gradually incorporate the olive oil and cream (if using) – as if you were making a thin mayonnaise.
- Add the herbs. Taste and adjust the seasoning to taste with salt (1/4 teaspoon at a time), pepper, or more vinegar if necessary.
- Prep Time: 10 minutes
This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure policy.
32 Comments on “Little Gems with Chez Panisse Green Goddess Dressing”
Little gems have not made it to my neck of the woods in Connecticut (although they made one brief appearance 2 years ago at Stop and Shop and vanished); however, my sister in Vermont is buying seeds and planting them at 2 week intervals to ensure an ongoing crop this summer. They are hearty enough for Vermont and therefore, I assume, hearty enough for shoreline Connecticut. Will keep you posted.
Please do! I would LOVE to do this as well. Such a great idea.
I’ve followed your blog for a few years now, and what a pleasant surprise to see you’ve visited my favorite restaurant in the Bay Area! Pizzaiolo is an Oakland gem (they also own Boot n’ Shoe and Penrose restaurants, also in Oakland, and both worth going to as well). I’ve always loved this salad. Thanks for the recipe!
So fun! Elissa, I ended up going to Pizzaiolo three times: once for dinner, once for breakfast, once for dinner to-go — it was sooooo good! I didn’t make it to Boot n Shoe but I’ve heard great things. Thanks so much for writing in!
I visited Boot and Shoe in August, during a weekend visit…it was a delicious brunch! Oakland is amazing!
So bummed I didn’t get there when I was visiting!
This sounds amazing! Can’t wait to try.
Thank you, Jamie!
Oh yum, those little lettuces look so crisp and beautiful! I’m a big fan of any kind of creamy dressing and have recently developed a love for anchovies, so I’ll definitely give this a go. Do you think the dressing will keep a few days in the fridge, or will the avocado make it go brown?
It will keep, Kelly! I’ve kept it as long as 3 days, but even at 3 days it wasn’t showing any signs of browning, so I think it’s safe to say it will keep for 3-5 days. The anchovies are subtle but so good. They make a difference.
Haven’t seen these gems around here (southwestern Ontario, Canada) but I have heard about them on the ‘net. This is the first time I have seen a picture of them. They look like Brussels sprouts; I’ll bet this dressing would go well with their leaves.
Yes, yum! Let me know how it goes if you try that. You could also use Romaine or really any lettuce—the dressing is so tasty.
This looks amazing..does the dressing keep for a few days in the fridge? Does it go brown?
The dressing amazingly keeps! I was worried the avocado would turn it brown, but it stays light green and tastes fresh. We’ve been going through a batch in about 3 days, so I would give it a 3- to 5-day fridge shelf life.
I had a very interesting salad at Skates on the Bay over in Berkeley – Grilled hearts of romaine, with a Caesar Parmesan dressing, heirloom cherry tomatoes, and a garnish of pickled shallots (this paired quite well with their artichoke crab dip and focaccia).
I may have to try my hand at this using little gems (I found the romaine hearts a bit on the tough side toward the center…I wonder how well little gems would survive the heat of the grill?) and substitute the Goddess dressing in lieu of the Caesar, a nice sprinkling of freshly grated Parmesan, some freshly cracked black pepper, and those lovely tomatoes. The shallots were okay, but they seemed more for show than anything else, so I could probably leave them off altogether, or maybe add some fresh julienne shallots or Bermuda onion? Hmm…the possibilities…
David this all sounds so good! I have not grilled little gems, but I have heard that they hold up extremely well on the grill…they’re sturdy little guys. Sweet but sturdy. The parm, the tomatoes, the pepper … yum! I am looking forward to grilling little gems this summer.
I’m going to give this a go this weekend, I think (weather permitting). Still racking my brain to figure out what to replace the avocado with (I’m deathly allergic to the little buggers, which stinks considering how packed full of vitamins they are) – any suggestions on a replacement for this?
Replying to myself here, for the benefit of others…I just found some interesting substitutions I could try, and if anyone reading this is, like me, allergic to avocados (and bananas…yep…latex issues), you might want to give these a go:
chayote squash (Once cooked, this works as an excellent low-calorie substitute for avocados in many dishes.)
(for guacamole) peas (Purée raw peas in a blender.) OR
(for guacamole) asparagus (Cook until tender, chill, then purée.) OR
(for guacamole) broccoli (Cook until tender, chill, then purée.) OR
(for salads) artichoke hearts
(for sandwich spread) Mayo or hummus
Just saved this recipe; I’ll definitely try making it and serve it as a dip with some raw veggies! Thanks for sharing! 🙂
yes! So yummy!
That salad looks out of this world – the avocados will make it I bet.
The avocado in the dressing is subtle but adds a really nice creaminess. Thanks!
Love this Green Goddess dressing. I had a jar in the fridge made with another recipe and was not at all enamored. After reading this recipe I added anchovy, avocado and cream to that batch and now am very happy with it. Thank you.
I’m a little late to the discussion but thank you for the recipe and explanation. I followed it, using tarragon, parsley, and cilantro as well as 1/2 tsp salt and about 1/4 tsp pepper and the dressing was too sour.
I then added more salt and basil and it was transformed. Delicious.
So happy to hear this Tatian! You can use less lemon/lime/vinegar to start, too, the next time you make it.
Hi- I just printed this recipe to try and wondered if I could use anchovy paste in place of the anchovies? If so, how much … and why did you stop adding anchovies and the cream to the salad dressing? Just curious which way I should make for the first time:)
Thanks in advance!
HI Deb! Absolutely you can use anchovy paste in place of the anchovies. Use a teaspoon to start. Add more to taste.
I think I stopped adding them because I received so many question from both vegan and dairy free people, who asked if they could omit. When I tried the versions without either, they were just as delicious, so I, too, stopped adding them. But definitely add them if you are curious. I think I do love the addition of the anchovy. I think the cream is optional.
Thank you for this recipe. Have searched for several years for a green goddess dressing. Everything fell short. This! I have been eating it for two days. Dipping romaine in it, vegetable, throwing it on my salad and I even dipped chicken meatballs in. I love it. It is tangy and creamy and like a good green goddess should make avocado hardboiled eggs taste like a dream. Did I say I love it! Thanks again.
Oh yay!! I love this 🙂 🙂 🙂 Thanks so much for writing, Amanda. Glad you are liking this one. I find it so refreshing and satisfying, too.
Holy cow is this good! Just made it tonight. I’m imagine I’ll try adding a jalapeno or serrano to next weeks batch for fun. Thank you for sharing this, it’s going in my permanent catalogue lol. Left out the cream and anchovies like you mentioned, it’s fantastic even without.
Great to hear this, Janine! I think something spicy would be so good here. Thanks for writing!