I know that some of you might be thinking there is no possible way you have time to add one more item, let alone homemade dinner rolls, to your Thanksgiving Day timetable, but I’m here on this snowy November morning to encourage — to insist! — that you do. You absolutely have time. Here’s why:
1. This dough, especially if you use instant yeast, takes five minutes to mix together. There is no kneading, no pampering.
2. Moreover, there is no need to flour up a workspace or to get your hands dirty shaping individual rolls. If you have a 12-cup muffin pan and someone lurking in your kitchen hoping to help, you’re in luck. Put that friend to work buttering the muffin cups, punching down the dough, portioning out the rolls. Handling this dough requires no skill.
3. This dough can rise in the corner of your kitchen all morning long. While that turkey roasts away, you can punch the dough down as often as you need, and when at last you find the oven free of birds and stuffings and gratins, in will go your rolls.
4. These rolls bake in 25 minutes. If you plan on letting your turkey rest for a good 30 minutes before carving, you’ll have plenty of time to let these rolls make their second rise (17 to 20 minutes) and to bake them before your guests are seated around the table, at which point you will pass around a basket of steaming hot, thyme-flecked rolls.
I know that from getting the turkey cooked to keeping the stuffing and the vegetables and the plates warm to keeping your guests entertained Thanksgiving can be a logistical nightmare challenge. And when there truly are so many wonderful take-and-bake options in your supermarket freezer, why not cross one thing off your to-do list?
Well, because if there ever was an occasion to push your domestic stamina to its limits, to display your culinary prowess, it’s Thanksgiving. I mean, where is the fun in effortless entertaining? Pony up, Friends. Nothing says you care like freshly baked bread (and turkey and stuffing and gravy and pumpkin pie and punch). Happy Thanksgiving, Everyone!
Flour, salt, sugar, SAF instant yeast and thyme:
Mixed dough:
First rise:
Dividing the dough:
Ready for second rise:
Ready for the oven:
Just baked:
I repeat, I could totally skip the turkey.
Have a wonderful holiday, Everyone! If you’re still looking for ideas, this board might help.
PrintThyme Dinner Rolls
-
Yield: 0 servings
Yield:
Print Recipe
Pin RecipeDescription
Note: This is yet another variation of the peasant bread. If you would prefer to make round loaves, view this post.
Ingredients
- 4 cups (1 lb. 2 oz | 510 g) all-purpose flour, preferably not bleached
- 2 teaspoons kosher salt
- 2 teaspoons sugar
- 2 teaspoons instant yeast or active dry yeast*
- 1 to 2 tablespoons minced fresh thyme leaves
- 2 cups lukewarm water**
- room temperature butter, about 2 tablespoons
* For future reference, you can buy both SAF instant yeast and Red Star active dry yeast in bulk from Amazon. After you open the pouches, transfer yeast to airtight container and store in the fridge or freezer, where they will last forever. If you are using the packets of yeast (the kind that come in the 3-fold packets), just go ahead and use a whole packet — I think it’s 2.25 teaspoons. Recently, I have been using instant yeast more than active dry because when you use instant yeast there is no need to do the proofing step — you can add the yeast directly to the flour — which makes the mixing process a little bit faster.
** To make fool-proof lukewarm water that will not kill the yeast (water that’s too hot can kill yeast), boil some water — I use my teapot. Then, mix 1 1/2 cups cold water with 1/2 cup boiling water. This ratio of hot to cold water will be the perfect temperature for the yeast.
Instructions
- If you are using instant yeast: In a large mixing bowl, whisk together the flour, salt, sugar, instant yeast, and fresh thyme leaves. Add the water. Mix until the flour is absorbed. Cover with plastic wrap (or a tea towel that has been run under hot water and squeezed out). Place in a warm spot to rise: Because your kitchen will likely be nice and cozy with all of the cooking going on, you don’t need to do the warm-oven rise trick. But for future reference, here is how you can create a warm spot: Turn your oven on (to 350 or so) and then turn it off after 1 minute — this will create just a slightly warm environment to get the bread rising nicely.If you are using active-dry yeast: In a small mixing bowl, dissolve the sugar into the water. Sprinkle the yeast over top. There is no need to stir it up. Let it stand for about 10 to 15 minutes or until the mixture is foamy and/or bubbling just a bit — this step will ensure that the yeast is active. Meanwhile, in a large bowl, whisk together the flour, salt and thyme. When the yeast-water-sugar mixture is foamy, stir it up, and add it to the flour bowl. Mix until the flour is absorbed. Cover with plastic wrap (or a tea towel that has been run under hot water and squeezed out). Place in a warm spot to rise: Because your kitchen will likely be nice and cozy with all of the cooking going on, you don’t need to do the warm-oven rise trick.
- Let dough rise for 1 to 2 hours or more or less. As noted in the post above, you can let the dough rise, and when you see that it has reached the top of the bowl, but you don’t have oven space available in the following 20 minutes, punch it down and let it rise again. You can do this as many times as necessary. Meanwhile, generously butter a 12-cup muffin pan, plus a few ramekins (2 to 4).
- Preheat the oven to 425ºF. Using two forks, punch down your dough, scraping it from the sides of the bowl, which it will be clinging to. (Here is video guidance. You can find more peasant bread-making video guidance at the end of the peasant bread post.) As you scrape it down, turn the dough up onto itself. You want to loosen the dough entirely from the sides of the bowl, and you want to make sure you’ve punched it down. Take your two forks and divide the dough roughly into 6 portions. Then, using the two forks, scoop up half of each of these portions and plop each into a buttered muffin cup. Repeat with remaining dough. This won’t be pretty, but it doesn’t matter. Try your best to divide the dough equally, and if you have extra dough, bake it off in the buttered ramekins. Let the dough rise for about 17 to 20 minutes or until it has risen to just above the top of the muffin cups.
- Bake for 15 minutes. Reduce the heat to 375º and make for 10 to 15 minutes longer. Remove from the oven and turn the rolls onto a cooling rack or directly into a bread basket. Pass the butter.
Katrina says
I love the peasant bread. I’ve made it twice already, each time substitutin some water for olive oil, and adding herbs de provence. After the 1st time, I bought your book. It’s great!
I made the coconut bread, but let it rise a lot longer than the 2 hours. Is it why the bread was sour?
★★★★★
alexandra says
Hi Katrina! Thank you so much for buying Bread Toast Crumbs! It means the world. Your herbs de provence variation sounds delicious. In regard to the coconut variation, it’s possible that the longer rise made it taste sour, but I can’t say for sure. Was it rising much more slowly than the other breads you’ve made? The sugar and coconut milk definitely slow down the rising, but I’m curious about your experience.
Laura says
I’ve made these at least half a dozen times and they never fail to turn out perfectly! Great recipe, great instructions!
★★★★★
Michelle says
I’ve made these several times, they are delicious and so easy to make! Thanks for the recipe.
★★★★★
alexandra says
Woohoo!
Rebecca says
Looking forwards to making these for Thanksgiving! I’ve become a big bread baker since getting your book over the summer – so much so that my family asked me to make the rolls this year instead of buying them! The only question I have is on how to reheat them. With the bread I make, generally the crispy crust is gone by the next day and comes back easily with a reheat. As I will probably have to make these the night before or very early on Thanksgiving (no chance I can win a fight for an oven during prime cooking time), what is your suggestion for reheating these or any other rolls I could make from your recipes so they are crispy and delicious again?
alexandra says
Hi! First, I’m so happy to hear about your bread baking, Rebecca! Second, very good questions. I typically bake them when the oven is free and the turkey is resting, but I do have this portable oven that I break out for holidays, so I understand if this is an impossibility if you are working with only one oven. You are absolutely right re the crust going soft after a day. The rolls will revive with a brief heating in the oven. If you can bake them on Thanksgiving morning, that is ideal — then, I would give them 15 minutes at 350 to warm up. Pop them in a tea-towel lined basket, and pass them around! Let me know if that answers your questions. Oh! If you have to bake them the day before. I would store them in ziplock bags, once they cool. Then reheat the same way. Happy Thanksgiving, Rebecca!
Rob says
Hi Alexandra,
Thanks for posting such a simple, delicious and unforgettable recipe. It has quickly become our favourite home made bread. I’ve only made the bread (not the rolls) and have found storing it in a brown paper bag lets the crust stay crispy. You can keep the bread in the paper bag for ~4 days without it becoming too hard. After 6 days (how did it not get eaten sooner?) the crust is quite hard but the inside is still soft and moist. The crust of the toast made from 6 day old bread is awesomely CRUNCHY and pairs very well with scrambled eggs.
Thanks again for this great recipe.
Cheers from Australia.
Rob
alexandra says
Wonderful to hear this, Rob! Thanks for taking the time to write. I’ve actually started storing my bread in paper bags as well. A friend gave me a Uashmama bag — washable paper bag — for my birthday a few weeks ago, and I absolutely love it. Incidentally, Uashmama is an Australian company. Do you know them? Love my Uashmama bags.
Angelina Whittle says
Help! Followed the instructions for instant yeast (not expired). and after 2 hours the dough hasn’t risen.☹️
Angelina says
Please Help! I followed the instructions for instant yeast and after 2 hours the dough still hasn’t risen. I then used the oven warming instructions and let it sit the oven for an hour and all that happened is the dough developed a cooked crispy crust.
alexandra says
Hi! So, your yeast isn’t expired, so that’s a good step. Question: how long did you preheat your oven for? It sounds as though it may have been too hot. You only want to preheat your oven for a minute total — it shouldn’t be hotter than 110ºF or so. Also, did you use lukewarm water: 1.5 cups cold water mixed with .5 cups boiling? Are you using a scale to measure your flour or measuring cups?
Angelina says
I microwaved water to 105 degrees. I normally let bread dough sit on top of a 250 degree oven. I was cooking on stove top this time and so let the bowl sit next to a large pot full of boiling water. Thought your instructions said heat oven to 350 and after a minute turn it off. That is what I did. I was going to o try to bake them anyway but it was late so I put the dough in the refrigerator and started reading about the possibility that adding yeast and trying to rise again might save the dough. I haven’t had time to add yeast yet, but took the dough out of the refrigerator and put it on top of an oven heated to 350 and then turned off. Any way to save this dough?
alexandra says
I think the issue is that your oven is too hot — you’re just trying to create a warm spot for your dough to rise. So, all you need to do is turn your oven on for a minute, then shut it off — it doesn’t matter what temp you set it to, the important thing is that it’s not hotter than 110 degrees or so. I think your dough has been cooking partially during the first “rise.” I would toss the dough and start over. I know it’s a bummer to waste ingredients, but I think you’re going to be more frustrated by putting more effort into this same batch of dough and not seeing any positive results in the end. Wish I were there to help!
Phil says
I’ve found tht just using the light in my oven bring the temp up to 96 degrees, and have not had a rise failure since.
alexandra says
Great tip Phil!
jackie drenth says
have you ever tried hand forming the rolls and baking on a sheet pan?
Gladys says
That won’t work with this dough. It is a very wet dough.
Julie says
I made this recipe Saturday night to serve on Sunday afternoon lunch after church meeting. I was feeling tired and rushed, so I made two loaves instead of rolls. Turned out delicious and this bread makes wonderful toast! I did not have fresh thyme on hand, so used dried thyme instead. I think that fresh thyme would have imparted more flavor and so next time I will use it.
Laura says
Hi Alexandra, I’ve been making your awesome peasant bread since your book came out and my entire family always devours it. I made these thyme rolls for the first time and they are amazing!! The buttery crust is the best part of your bread. So with the rolls, you get a lot more crust. I added a teaspoon of garlic powder also and the combination is perfect. I’ve got to go walk 5K more steps now!
Leah says
Hi Alexandra, I made these rolls and the flavor is amazing. Unfortuanately they were very tough and chewy. Do you have any ideas as to what could have happened? I’m a novice bread baker, so any advice is appreciated! I’m hoping to improve the texture so I can make them for Thanksgiving.
Thanks!
Leah
alexandra says
Hi Leah! Sorry for the delay here. Questions: how long did you let the first rise go? Did it look OK? as in doubled? One thing that might help the texture is to increase the length of the first rise. Try for 2 hours. And then make sure the dough is creeping above the rim of the pan before putting the pan in the oven. Hope that helps!
Ali says
I love your regular peseant bread recipe, and have made it multiple times, it’s always a hit! I looked at this recipe because I wanted to make rolls instead of loaves. Can you double the recipe (for your peasant bread in general), and leave some dough resting while some is baking? Or is it better to do it one batch at a time. Also how long should you leave it in the oven for rolls
★★★★★
alexandra says
Yes, you can double the recipe! And yes, you can leave some dough resting, while half of it bakes off in bowls or muffin cups or whatever. Rolls bake for about 25 minutes. See the recipe for times and temperatures. So happy you like this one.
Taylor says
Made this today for a Thanksgiving practice run. I am totally ashamed to say that my husband and I each had four rolls straight out of the oven. They were sooooo good and so easy. We skipped lunch, so whatever, it all evens out.
★★★★★
alexandra says
So happy to hear this, Taylor! And it totally evens out … you’re good 🙂 🙂 🙂
GoodCooker says
Should either the dough or the baked rolls freeze well? I just harvested a bounty of fresh thyme, but it likely won’t last through the holidays.
alexandra says
Oh yes! The bread freezes beautifully. Wait for it to cool completely; then freeze it in an airtight container. Love these!
Laura says
How best to reheat after they have been frozen? Also, will they be as good after a stint in the freezer?
alexandra says
Hi! I would thaw at room temperature. Then heat on a sheet pan or heat-safe bowl for 15 minutes at 350ºF or so.
If you freeze the rolls when they are freshly baked (once they have cooled completely, of course), they will reheat beautifully!
Lynett says
Made these today for Thanksgiving and everyone loved them! I used rosemary instead of thyme cuz that’s what was growing in the yard. They were wonderful and as forgiving as advertised. It got punched down three times and haphazardly divided into 13 rolls and I still had to hide some to kepp guests from taking them all home. Thanks again, Alexandra!
★★★★★
alexandra says
Oh I love it! Thanks so much for writing in. So happy the process was easy and adaptable to your kitchen/baking schedule. Happy happy Thanksgiving!
Cathy says
So easy, so wonderful! New Thanksgiving tradition for my family. Had to leave out the thyme because young children/green stuff. Thankful for this recipe and such clear instructions.
alexandra says
So happy to hear this, Cathy!