This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure policy.
Friends! One week + one day till Thanksgiving. Are you ready? Are you hosting? I’m hosting a smallish gathering of 9 adults and 8 children. I can’t wait.
Menu: Thanksgiving 2018
• Philadelphia Fish House Punch (my favorite, what I look forward to most)
• Alice Waters’s Potato Gratin (my second favorite… I live for these potatoes (after punch))
• Salad: Greens with Shaved Cabbage, Fennel, Manchego and Candied Pepitas (very festive and seasonal)
• Freezable Stuffing with Caramelized Onion and Kale (adapted from this one)
• Turkey (stay tuned!) + Gravy — going to wet brine my turkey following a Sally Schneider recipe I used years ago
• Sauces: Red Wine Cranberry Sauce | No-Cook Cranberry Sauce | Applesauce
• No-Knead Thyme Dinner Rolls
• Ronnie Hollingsworth’s Most Excellent Squash Pie
• Bourbon Pecan Pie (No Corn Syrup) with Salted Whipped Cream
• Apple-Frangipane Galette
To prepare, in the next few days I’ll make a double batch of my favorite all-purpose pie dough, which I’ll freeze till next week and which I’ll use in all three desserts. At some point, I’ll juice the lemons, make the simple syrup, and freeze the ice ring for the punch. I’ll make bread to use for the stuffing, and I’ll make a large-batch shallot vinaigrette for the salad. All of the sauces will be made in the days leading up to Thanksgiving, and I’ll assemble and freeze the stuffing early next week as well.
I like to bake my desserts the morning of Thanksgiving, before the turkey goes in the oven. This year I have the luxury of having a second oven, so I’ll assemble the gratin while the turkey roasts.
Friends, what do you like to do? How are your preparations going? Are you trying anything new? I feel it’s fun to try one new dish every year. Not sure what it’s going to be this year…
Hope all of your Thanksgiving preparations are going well.
More: Thanksgiving Ideas Here | Desserts Here | Side Dishes Here
As noted above, I’ll be wet-brining a turkey using a recipe I used years ago and loved. I will be sure to report back.
Question: Where do you all get your turkey? I recently learned about Farm To Table Online (affiliate link), which is an organization that works with small, family farms who are committed to treating animals humanely and practicing sustainable agriculture. It’s not too late to get a turkey from them! But you must order one by tomorrow, November 15th, to guarantee delivery by Thanksgiving.
Philadelphia Fish House Punch. I highly recommend this Fish House punch if you’re looking for something festive. I’ve made it for every major holiday since discovering it about 4 years ago now. It calls for 1.5 cups of freshly squeezed lemon juice. Lemons can be juiced several days in advance; simple syrup can be made in advance; ice ring must be made in advance. Of course, there will be Prosecco on hand, too.
ON THE SIDE
Alice Waters’s Potato Gratin: I could totally skip the turkey. Love these potatoes so much:
Ina Garten’s Roasted Brussels Sprouts with Balsamic: These Brussels sprouts are not a staple, but I love them. I also recently made them without the pancetta, and they were still completely delicious. If I were to make these for Thanksgiving, I would omit the pancetta:
No matter what stuffing I make, I always follow the same method, the essential steps for me being to remove tough crusts from whatever loaf of bread I am using and to toast (as opposed to stale) the bread with a generous amount of olive oil. Stuffing, I think, is personal, so add what you like. I’ve bulleted the basic method below, but for more detailed quantities and instructions, see this post: Stuffing Two Ways, which has the two stuffing recipes from Bread Toast Crumbs.
- Remove the crusts from loaf of bread (unless using the peasant bread).
- Tear into pieces or cut into cubes, toss with a generous amount of olive oil and a good pinch of salt, and toast until golden.
- Add mix-ins of choice. Sautéed onions are essential for me, and I love greens, like chard or kale. I also prefer to keep stuffing meatless, but if you like sausage or oyster or whatever (a little bacon or pancetta never hurts), go for it.
- Taste and make sure the mixture of bread and mix-ins is well seasoned. Whisk a good amount of stock with 1 egg, which helps bind the stuffing, toss with your stuffing mix, then bake until golden.
Also, you can make stuffing ahead of time, freeze it uncooked, and bake it directly from the freezer. I wrote about this method for Food52. Notes here. Recipe here.
Do you make a salad for Thanksgiving? I do, and I’m a believer for two reasons: 1. It offers an element of fresh in a sea of cooked and 2. Logistically it’s very practical, requiring not an oven to reheat or much prep or forethought in general. Last year, I made this one — Shaved Cabbage, Fennel, and Greens with Citrus Vinaigrette, Manchego and Candied Pepitas — and I’m making it again this year.
Cranberry Sauce Two Ways: On the left: No-Cook Cranberry Relish (this is a new one for me, love it); On the right: Sally Schneider’s Red Wine Cranberry Sauce (old favorite; recently made it with Port and loved it)
We always have applesauce on the table, too. I forget which apples I used to get the beautiful hue in the photo below (pink lady?), but I make applesauce just as my mother does with unpeeled apples and nothing but water — no cinnamon, sugar, lemon, spices, etc. Here is the recipe: Homemade Applesauce. (Note: The picture below is from this post for Applesauce Yogurt Cake, which is such a good one to have on hand for the holidays.) Applesauce and cake can be made ahead of time.
And if we’re making ham, we always make my grandmother’s mustard sauce, also known as — wait for it — the ham sauce!
These No-Knead Thyme Dinner Rolls (left) are a variation of the peasant bread with the addition of thyme and baked in muffin tins instead of bowls. They can be baked ahead, cooled, and frozen, then reheated on Thanksgiving, but another easy thing to do is this: mix* the dough in the morning (because what else will you have to do?), let it rise on the counter all day, punching it down as needed if it gets too high, then, during the last 20 minutes of the turkey’s cooking time, transfer the dough to buttered muffin cups, and bake the rolls when the turkey is resting. Easy peasy. You can do it! | You could do the same thing with the peasant bread (right) recipe. Let me know if you have any other bread questions. *To get a jump start on the mixing, you can measure the flour, salt, and sugar the night before, and stick it in a ziplock bag or covered bowl until the morning, at which point you’ll just have to add the instant yeast and water.
If you are yeast averse — which you should not be! — biscuits are a great option. Here are two: Joanne Chang’s Buttermilk Biscuits | Buttermilk Cheddar Biscuits
I’m making three desserts: Apple-Frangipane Galette (left), which is super easy (video guidance on that one—dough comes together in seconds with the food processor) and Ronnie Hollingsworth’s Most Excellent Squash Pie (right), which I love. This one is also easy (though you do have to roast a butternut squash as opposed to open a can of pumpkin), and I do not blind bake the crust anymore, which helps simplify the process. The third one is a bourbon pecan pie (no corn syrup) from David Lebovitz, which I made recently and really loved. I left out the fresh, dried, and candied ginger. Hoping to post about that one before Thursday. Will keep you posted.
If you’re hosting any vegetarians, I highly recommend this Butternut Squash Lasagna, an old Gourmet recipe that my aunt’s friend introduced the family to when she brought it to Thanksgiving in Vermont a few years ago. It’s one of my favorites. I repeat: I could skip the turkey.
Four Nice Cakes To Have Around
Each of these four cakes gets better by the day, so don’t be afraid to bake them ahead of time.
Teddie’s Apple Cake | Orange and Olive Oil Cake | Chez Panisse Almond Torte | Applesauce Yogurt Cake
Bye for now! Good luck! Gobble Gobble!
This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure policy.
20 Comments on “Thanksgiving 2018”
Oh wow! That spread looks and sounds awesome!!! Have room for one more??? ???????????? Happy Thanksgiving, Alexandra!!
I really think I want to make one more pie … or one of those beautiful, shingled, sweet potato gratins. Will keep you posted!
Ha ha ha… I meant one more guest… but i’ll settle for another pie recipe ????
Those questiom marks are suppose to be a laughing emoji 🙂
hahaha, ok, got it!! YES we have room for you… door is open 🙂 🙂 🙂
Any gravy advice Alexandra?
Maybe by early next week! My mom is not really a gravy person, and as a result, gravy to me has meant mostly drippings + stock … in other words, it tastes like a thickened, rich stock, which I love, but which I know is not traditional. I made do what another commenter suggested, which is to make the gravy ahead of time. Stay tuned!
I’ve been a huge advocate of make ahead gravy – partial to the recipe from Noble Pig since that’s where I got the idea, but Food Wishes does a similarly good one. Last minute pan dripping gravy used to be a 50/50 success rate for me. Some years it comes out super easy, other years it turns into an oily, congealed mess. After I started making gravy ahead of time and just reheating, that’s one less last-minute hassle to deal with.
SMART!! Love this idea. Thanks for the tip. I think I’m going to do this. Also, I love Noble Pig. Miss her regular posts but it’s always fun to see what she’s up to 🙂
Alexandra’s red wine cranberry sauce is FABULOUS! I’ve been making this since originally published. The best!
Awww you’re the sweetest … so happy to hear this!!
Adding the buttermilk dinner rolls from Bread Toast Crumbs this year – really excited to have these at the table. Was planning on baking in advance, freezing, and then defrosting/reheating the day of, but was wondering if the melted butter that gets brushed on the finished rolls should be added immediately after baking or if I should wait until after reheating?
Awwwww, this makes me so happy! I think you should wait till after reheating them. Great idea re making ahead, freezing, and reheating day of. Have a Happy Thanksgiving!!
Wow, thank you for taking the trouble to put this menu together with all the links. It sounds awesome and I am totally stealing ideas from here. I go to my in-laws for thanksgiving but they just order their entire meal from Boston market and call it a day ……ugh, but to each his own . So I like to cook a small pre-thanksgiving meal for my own little family and it’s all vegetarian since I am too ;-). I tried ur stuffing recipe with kale and onions and it was awesome last year. This time, I am doing the Farro risotto, the shaved cabbage salad and the punch (I’ve got a loaded lemon tree just waiting). Happy Thanksgiving Ali!
That menu honestly sounds perfect to me … I sound like a broken record, but I could totally skip the turkey. The farro risotto is a favorite as is the salad and, of course, the punch! I sip on that punch all day long, then usually take an epic post-meal nap. It’s the best. Happy Happy Thanksgiving!!
thank you for all of this inspiration, wow, and broken down even into sauces, veg, etc, great idea
Thank you, Sabrina!! xo
I just want to be there for this feast! Especially the pie! ❤️????❤️ Happy Thanksgiving Lady!
Happy Thanksgiving to you Laurie!! Big hugs xoxo